Home News Opinion – The US-Japan Alliance Continues to Stand for Democracy, Regardless of...

Opinion – The US-Japan Alliance Continues to Stand for Democracy, Regardless of a Position Reversal


On April 16, U.S. President Joe Biden hosted Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga on the White Home, making Suga the primary overseas chief to make such a go to below Biden’s presidency. The joint statement after the summit mentioned they ‘underscore the significance of peace and stability throughout the Taiwan Strait and encourage the peaceable decision of cross-Strait points.’ The final time a U.S. president and a Japanese prime minister talked about Taiwan in a joint assertion was 1969, years earlier than Washington and Tokyo normalized their diplomatic ties with Beijing. The assertion additionally expressed shared issues ‘relating to the human rights conditions in Hong Kong and the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Area.’ It is a welcome improvement as a result of the political roles of the US and Japan of their seven-decades-old alliance are experiencing a serious shift.

In alliance politics, relations between allies are largely outlined by the worry of abandonment and entrapment, particularly in relation to their major adversaries. Throughout the U.S.-Japan alliance, Tokyo within the final decade was extra involved about abandonment by the US within the face of rising Chinese language assertiveness within the East China Sea whereas Washington worried that the dispute between Japan and China would possibly entangle the US right into a navy battle. Allies’ issues are not limited to military risks, and so they usually lengthen to problems with financial coverage and even worldwide norms.

With a robust emphasis on democracy and human rights, Biden as a presidential candidate had proposed to host a world summit for democracy in his first yr as president, and he remarked on March 25 that he was ‘going to invite an alliance of democracies to come’ to the US and so they have been ‘going to carry China accountable to observe the foundations.’ After initially worrying that the Biden administration would possibly take a conciliatory strategy towards China, Japanese policymakers now appear to be involved concerning the prices of being dragged into the confrontation between the US and China. Japan is the one member of G7 that has not joined the current sanctions in opposition to China for its human rights abuses, and Japan’s ‘weak-kneed attitude’ has been criticized domestically in addition to internationally.

A decade in the past, in distinction, it was Tokyo that was putting an emphasis on common values in its diplomacy and the necessity to counter Beijing, because the Sino-Japanese maritime territorial dispute escalated from round 2010. In a 2012 opinion piece titled ‘Asia’s Democratic Security Diamond,’ the previous prime minister Shinzo Abe wrote that ‘Japan’s diplomacy should all the time be rooted in democracy,’ and the Asia-Pacific areas’ future prosperity ought to relaxation on common values, whereas he advocated elevated cooperation with Australia, India, and the US. Though Washington was already rising its consideration to the area, many Japanese policymakers on the time seen the Obama administration as too soft on China.

This position reversal is pure as a result of threat perceptions are a serious driving drive for alliance politics, however Washington and Tokyo should set an instance of democratic solidarity that stays above the fluctuating short-term geopolitical calculations. Democratic solidarity will not be solely necessary for the sake of common values but additionally for the long-term materials pursuits of the allies.

Not like within the early years of the Chilly Warfare, democracies are now not a small minority within the worldwide society. In reality, 99 out of 166 international locations Polity5 Project coded have been thought-about democratic in 2018. Tutorial analysis has additionally proven that democratic allies are extra reliable in military crises, much less prone to abrogate alliance agreements opportunistically, extra prone to prevail in military conflicts, and extra prone to cooperate with one another economically. Provided that the overwhelming majority of nations that the US has alliance obligations to defend are democratic (52 out of 66 in 2018) and lots of of them face navy threats from autocracies similar to China and Russia, advocating democratic solidarity is certainly good Realpolitik. Such a technique is especially necessary after the previous president Donald Trump rejected the significance of alliances and democracy in U.S. overseas coverage.

In brief, democratic solidarity brings quite a few advantages that aren’t associated to the exclusion and containment of China. Chinese language leaders naturally have criticized the Biden administration’s give attention to democracy, arguing that the US should abandon ‘the Cold War mentality and the zero-sum game approach.’ China’s Foreign Ministry spokesman warned the Japanese that they ‘hope Japan may be prudent about its actions and rhetoric, and doesn’t make groundless assaults on China simply because it’s an ally of the U.S.’ There may be an inevitable pressure between democratic solidarity and engagement of China, however it’s important that the US and Japan present that their dedication to democracy will not be a canopy for the containment of China.

As a non-Western nation with a protracted historical past of democracy and the previous enemy of the US, Japan has a particular position to play within the promotion of democratic solidarity advocated by Biden. The alliance between the primary and third largest economies of the world boasts sturdy materials capabilities, however the US and Japan ought to lead the world by the ability of their instance, as Biden urged for the management of the US in his inaugural address.

It’s time for Japan to sign its dedication to common values by taking expensive measures. This implies standing as much as China, its largest buying and selling companion, in addition to taking a extra energetic position on different points. Commenting on the repression of democratic protests in Myanmar and geopolitical competitors, the Excessive Consultant of the European Union Josep Borrell not too long ago wrote that the EU has been ‘reaching out to all key stakeholders (ASEAN, China, Japan, India)’ and ‘like-minded companions, notably the US and UK.’ Japan’s pragmatic diplomacy has its personal deserves, however solidarity with ‘like-minded’ democratic companions is more and more necessary. The U.S.-Japan joint assertion, subsequently, was a step in the fitting course.

In flip, the US should additionally show that its advocacy of democracy is not only for geopolitical competitors with China. Professional-democracy diplomacy will at occasions alienate some international locations and provides short-term geopolitical benefit to Beijing. The advantages of constant democratic solidarity, nevertheless, outweighs its prices. Collectively, Tokyo and Washington should present the multifaceted energy of a democratic alliance.

Additional Studying on E-Worldwide Relations